Discussions, Reviews, , ,

A guide to my book reviews and rating system

Dear readers,

I want to get back into actually reviewing the books I read and found it necessary to clarify for myself how I will go about reviewing them and deciding on the rating I will give a book… and since I plan on sharing all my reviews with you, I considered it useful to also share the premise and rating system my reviews are based on.

What is the aim of a review?

Personally, I have a very ambivalent relationship with book reviews as I don’t really consider them a useful tool to choose my next read. It is no secret that the same book usually has reviews that range from glowing praise to people picking apart its numerous flaws. So unless I know someone’s reading taste is very similar to my own (which is rarely the case), reading a positive or negative review of a book does not tell me whether I will actually like a book. What it might do, however, is influence the way I experience the book when reading it because it directs my attention to certain aspects of the book and presents them the way the reviewer experienced them. Personally, I prefer going into a book blindly and forming my own opinion before discussing it with other readers, so I tend to avoid reading reviews beforehand.

Since reviews are of so little use to me when finding new books to read, I tried out several different review methods, unsure which one to stick with, as I was not in the clear as to what I was trying to achieve with them in the first place: Should I only focus on reviewing books I enjoyed, if my goal was to help people find their new favourite books? Should I try and offer a more neutral presentation of a book, so people might be able to grasp what the book is about without being influenced by my own opinion of it? Should I keep it spoiler-free or go into detail about the different aspects I liked and disliked? So many questions I did not have an answer to, that ultimately had me abandon reviews altogether…

For now, I think my mind is clearer on the purpose of my reviews. I want them to be a way for me to critically reflect on the book I have read and to make up my mind on the aspects I liked and disliked, and why this was the case. That can then serve as a starting point for discussing the book with others who have read it.

This of course influences the way I structure my reviews, what information I include, and how I decide on my rating. I do not want to objectively judge a book’s quality, rather I want it to reflect my individual experience while reading the book.

How will I write my reviews?

I plan on keeping the review two-fold:

  1. A short presentation of the book with an overview over aspects I appreciated or disliked. This will be spoiler-free and might serve any people who find reviews more useful than I do when it comes to choosing their next read.
  2. A more in-depth discussion of the contents of the book and anything that stood out to me, with an analysis of the different aspects I appreciated or disliked, as well as why (I think) this was the case, etc. This part of the review will include spoilers as it is supposed to reflect my experience reading the book, which is inevitably tied to the specific contents.

How will I decide on a rating?

I read different books for different reasons, depending on the type of book it is and why I chose to add it to my TBR. Therefore, one five star read does not equal another five star read. However, I do have a broad system in place to lend my ratings at least some sort of coherence.

I am obsessed with this book. I was deeply invested in the story and it will not let me out of its grasp in the foreseeable future.

I enjoyed reading this book and there wasn’t anything specific I disliked, however it didn’t quite grip me enough to make me obsessed with it.

I enjoyed this book overall, but there were some aspects I disliked.

This book wasn’t for me, nevertheless there were some aspects to it that I appreciated.

I regret reading this book, many things stood out to me negatively and I found little to no aspects that I liked.

As you see, the rating system is very focused on my individual experience with a book. Because every book has its merits, and every book has its flaws, but what is interesting to me is ultimately how I “lived” the story.

I hope this clears some things up and gives you a better understanding of my review and rating system! Feel free to weigh into the debate about reviews in the comments and share your own perspective on which purpose reviews serve and how you decide on a rating for a book!

Yours,

Maya